Week In Review

Headnotes of selected Florida Supreme Court and District Courts of Appeal cases filed the week of
November 16, 2026 - November 20, 2026

Civil Law Headnotes (Jump to Criminal Law Headnotes)

THESE ARE NOT ALL OF THE CASES RELEASED BY THE COURTS FOR THE WEEK.
To see others not presented here, log in for more comprehensive weekly listings.

Attorney's fees -- Proposal for settlement -- Premature -- Final judgment -- Trial court erred by awarding defendant attorney's fees and costs based upon proposal for settlement where no judgment had been entered on jury's verdict -- An award of attorney's fees and costs prior to the entry of a final judgment on issue of liability is premature and will be reversed -- Court rejects argument that final judgment on motion for attorney's fees constituted final judgment in case because first five words of judgment are “pursuant to the jury verdict” -- Because defendant never sought a judgment on the verdict, trial court cannot be said to have entered relief that was not requested -- Furthermore, first five words of judgment fail to say what jury verdict was, leaving open question of liability or what the jury found and for whom
VIEW OPINION (login required)

Small claims -- Dismissal -- Trial court erred by granting motion to dismiss complaint because motion was procedurally improper -- Small Claims Rules do not authorize a defendant's motion for dismissal before plaintiff presents evidence, and trial court failed to properly invoke Rules of Civil Procedure -- A party cannot unilaterally invoke the Rules of Civil Procedure by filing a motion premised on those rules' application, and merely granting a motion brought under Rules of Civil Procedure does not establish that court invoked those rules
VIEW OPINION (login required)

Torts -- Bars and lounges -- Dram Shop Act -- Action brought against bar which served plaintiff alcohol before she was struck by a vehicle while trying to walk across highway intoxicated -- No error in granting summary judgment in favor of defendant based on determination that defendant did not know that plaintiff was habitually addicted to use of any or all alcoholic beverages when it served plaintiff -- Evidence was insufficient to show that defendant knew plaintiff was habitually addicted to use of any or all alcoholic beverages where defendant served alcoholic beverages to plaintiff for the first time on date of incident, plaintiff consumed approximately 2.5 beverages over the course of several hours, and plaintiff showed no signs of impairment
VIEW OPINION (login required)

Criminal Law Headnotes (Jump to Civil Law Headnotes)

THESE ARE NOT ALL OF THE CASES RELEASED BY THE COURTS FOR THE WEEK.
To see others not presented here, log in for more comprehensive weekly listings.

Criminal law -- Murder -- Death penalty -- Jury trial -- Waiver -- Voluntariness -- Competency of defendant -- Trial court did not violate defendant's due process rights by accepting his waiver of penalty-phase jury while he was allegedly incompetent -- Because defendant had previously been found competent and there was record evidence of continued competency, there was no bona fide doubt raised in the proceedings such that trial court was required to reassess defendant's competency -- Trial court properly inquired into whether defendant's waiver of penalty-phase jury was knowing and voluntary -- Record shows that defendant understood right he was waiving and the strategic disadvantages of a bench trial -- Cruel and/or unusual punishment -- State's abandonment of proportionality review and alleged failure to limit class of persons eligible for death penalty does not render capital sentencing scheme unconstitutional
VIEW OPINION (login required)

Criminal law -- Sentencing -- Death penalty -- Post conviction relief -- Successive motion -- Newly discovered evidence -- Mitigating evidence brought to light by Dozier Act -- Dismissal of third successive motion for post conviction relief based on conclusion that appellant's attempt to raise newly discovered evidence based on 2024 Dozier Act was untimely and procedurally barred -- Court has previously held that Dozier Act expressed a public stance predicated on reports, data, and research that have been publicly available for years and did not constitute newly discovered evidence -- Additionally, claim was procedurally barred because record established that abuse appellant suffered at Dozier school in 1970s could have and should have been raised earlier
VIEW OPINION (login required)

Criminal law -- Witnesses -- Bias -- Cross-examination -- Limitation -- Trial court erred by prohibiting defense from revealing witness's employment with investigating law enforcement agency which had asked witness to review surveillance footage from which he identified defendant -- Defendant was not required to show that witness's relationship with law enforcement agency actually influenced witness before questioning him about it -- Error was not harmless where identity of shooter remained a disputed issue at trial, witness played a central role in law enforcement agency's identification of defendant, and state relied on witness's asserted lack of interest in case -- Questioning witness about his memory and opportunity to recognize defendant did not substitute for an opportunity to explore employment relationship as a possible source of bias
VIEW OPINION (login required)

Criminal law -- Witnesses -- Bias -- Cross-examination -- Limitations -- Trial court erred by prohibiting defendant from cross-examining her ex-husband regarding the fact that defendant had previously accused ex-husband's mother of sexual abuse -- Defendant was entitled to cross-examine state's witness regarding any grounds that may cause witness to be biased against her, and fact that defendant accused ex-husband's mother of sexual abuse was a possible reason for ex-husband to be biased against defendant -- Error was not harmless merely because ex-husband was questioned regarding other reasons he had negative feelings toward defendant -- Examination of witness regarding facts surrounding one possible ground for bias is no substitute for the right to cross-examine witness regarding a different ground for bias
VIEW OPINION (login required)